THE RIGHT TO DEFENSE OF THE MINOR SUSPECTS AND ACCUSED IN THE CRIMINAL PROCEDURAL LEGISLATION OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION
Palavras-chave:
minor, criminal proceedings, criminal case, crime, criminal procedure law, law, defense, right, suspect, accused, subject, modelResumo
the relevance of the study is due to the problem of the alienation of criminal procedural regulation from the social and legal realities that determine the specifics of the realization of the right to defense of a minor who is being prosecuted. The right to defense, as the norm and principle and legal priority for the defense, permeates all criminal proceedings. In this regard, this article is aimed at determining the content of the right to defense of a minor suspect or accused, identifying some significant shortcomings of criminal procedural regulation from the standpoint of their elimination and proposing corrective measures of normative nature. The leading approach to the study of this problem is the analysis of scientific, legal and empirical materials that make it possible to comprehensively consider the normative and law enforcement potential of criminal procedural legislation in terms of comprehensive, full regulation of the right to defense of minors in criminal proceedings. The article contains the author's definitions of the right to defense, describes the procedural model for the protection of minor suspects and accused, reveals the main procedural differences in the provision and implementation of the right to the defense of minors; defines the procedure for clarifying the rights of minors granted by law, justifies the purpose of the criminal proceedings against minors. The materials of the article are of practical value for the establishment and application of the norms of the criminal procedural legislation in the protection of the rights and legitimate interests of criminally prosecuted persons of a minor age, regardless of their status. The present paper is part of the dissertation research devoted to the substantiation of new, socially-oriented provisions and the corresponding practical recommendations for improving the effectiveness of the Russian criminal procedure law for persons aged 14 to 18 as the most vulnerable category of suspects and accused in criminal cases to ensure their right to defense. The obtained results represent new theoretical and practical provisions describing the main distinctive features of the right to defend a minor suspect or accused in the criminal procedure of the Russian Federation.
Downloads
Não há dados estatísticos.
Referências
Avialani, K.A. Features of pre-trial proceedings in criminal cases against minors. Diss. ... cand. jurid. sciences. Kemerovo, 2009. 237p.
Agaltsova, M.V. The development of juvenile justice in the countries of the Council of Europe / Improving the mechanisms of working with juvenile offenders in the Russian Federation. Collection of analytical materials. M .: Informpoligraf, LLC. 2010. P.p.52-59.
Arutunyan, A.A. Mediation in criminal proceedings. Moscow: Infotropic Media, 2013. 200 p.
Balakina, V.S. Features of the lawyer's work with under-aged clients // Prospects for the development of juvenile law and juvenile justice in the Russian Federation: materials of the All-Russian Scientific and Practical Conference / Comp. L.A. Chikin, A.V. Yakovlev. Pomor State University named after M.V. Lomonosov. Arkhangelsk: Pomor University, 2008. P.p.11-17.
Bydantsev, N.A. Termination of criminal prosecution (case) against a minor with the use of compulsory measures of educational influence in the aspect of juvenile justice: monograph. M .: Shumilova I.M. Publishing house, 2008. 159 p.
Borisevich, G.Ya. On the implementation of the ideas of juvenile justice in the criminal justice of Russia // Bulletin of Perm University. Juridical sciences. 2015. № 1 (27). P.p.93-104.
Borovik, O.V. Peculiarities of pre-trial proceedings in criminal cases in relation to minors: diss ... cand. sc. (jurisprudence). M, 2006. 176p.
Vasilenko, A.S. Use of elements of restorative justice in criminal proceedings against minors in Russia and the USA / A.S. Vasilenko, L.T.Chikhladze, S.M. Naurzalieva // Man: crime and punishment. 2017. Vol. 25 (1-4). № 3. P.p. 394-398.
Vaske, E.V. Evolution of juvenile delinquency in Russia: a psychological and legal analysis. Moscow: Genesis, 2010. 428 p.
Volodina, L.M. Problems in the theory of the criminal process / Collection of articles on the materials of the International Scientific and Practical Conference "Scientific School of Criminal Process and Criminalistics of St. Petersburg State University and Modern Legal Science". Krasnoyarsk: Center for Social and Legal Technologies, 2016. P.p.59-68.
Volynskaya, O.V. Termination of the criminal case and criminal prosecution: theoretical and organizational and legal problems: monograph. Moscow: Unity-Dana: Zakon I pravo, 2007. 256 p.
The Universal Declaration of Human Rights (adopted at the third session of the UN General Assembly by resolution 217 a (III) of December 10, 1948) // The Garant system. [Electronic resource].
Gukovskaya, N.I., Dolgova, A.I., Minkovsky, G.M. Investigation and trial of cases of crimes of minors. M., 1974. 290 p.
Dudina, A.N. The concept and signs of peremptory norms of law (theoretical and legal analysis). // Izvestiya of the Irkutsk State Economic Academy (Baikal State University of Economics and Law). 2015. Vol.6, №2. P.p.22-31.
Dikarev, I.S. The principle of increased protection of the rights and legitimate interests of minors // Russian Justice. 2007. № 5. P.p. 24-26.
Zabuga, E.E. Mediation as an alternative form of criminal prosecution of minors. Diss. ... cand. jurid. sciences. Omsk, 2014. 261 p.
Kalugina, N.G. Ethical bases of separate investigative actions in cases of crimes of minors. Abstract of diss. .... Cand. sc. (jurisprudence). Izhevsk, 1996, 24p.
Koludarova, O.P. Production in criminal cases against neglected minors of suspects, accused. Abstract of diss. .... Cand. sc. (jurisprudence). Izhevsk, 2011. 29 p.
Kiryanina, N.A. Ensuring the rights of minors in criminal proceedings in the stage of the criminal case: Author's abstract of dissertation ... Cand. sc. (jurisprudence). Nizhny Novgorod, 2010. 28 p.
Kirsanov, V.N. Psychopathology of adolescence / Support for juvenile justice: a methodical manual for judges. Saratov: Publishing house "Saratov State Academy of Law", 2003. P.p.42 - 48.
Konin, V. V, Mukhina, G.A. Protection of minors: establishment of psychological contact / Actual problems of criminal proceedings in relation to minors: materials of the All-Russian Scientific and Practical Conference (November 23, 2007). Kaliningrad .: Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia, 2008. P.p. 58 - 62.
Kolokolov, N.A., Revina, I.V., Ryabinina, T.K., Chebotareva, I.N., Eriashvili, N.D. Lawyer in criminal proceedings. M .: Unity - Dana: Zakon I pravo, 2012. 375 p.
Kostina, L.N. Features of interaction of the investigator with the officers of the inquiry and the psychologist in enhancing the effectiveness of the investigation and prevention of juvenile crimes. Human and civil rights and freedoms: Actual problems of science and practice: Proceedings of the II International Scientific and Practical Conference. Orel: ORAGS Publishing House, 2011. P.p.299 - 307;
Kolpakova, L.A., Rudakov, A.M. The system of juvenile justice in Russia and abroad: monograph. Vologda: Vologda Institute of Economics and Law of the Federal Penitentiary Service of Russia, 2016. 109 p.
Levchenko, O. V., Mishchenko, E. V. Legal basis for criminal proceedings in relation to minors: Monograph. Moscow: INFRA-M, 2012. 125 p.
Lunichev, E.M. The status of a minor in criminal law: monograph / otv. Ed. AI Chuchaev. Moscow: Prospekt, 2012. 144 p.
Makhov, V.N., Vasilenko, A.S., Chebukhanova, L.V. Elements of Restorative Justice in Criminal Proceedings // Bulletin of Perm University. Juridical sciences. 2017. № 35. P.p.107 - 121;
Markovicheva, E.V. Juvenualnoe criminal justice proceedings. Models, functions, principles: monograph. M .: UNITY-DANA: Zakon I pravo, 2010. 271 p.
The UN Standard Minimum Rules for the Administration of Juvenile Justice ("The Beijing Rules") (adopted by UN General Assembly Resolution 40/33 of December 10, 1985) // The Garant System. [Electronic resource].
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights of December 16, 1966 // SPS "Consultant Plus". [Electronic resource].
Convention on the Rights of the Child (New York, November 20, 1989) // The Garant System. [Electronic resource].
Melnikova, E.B. Juvenile justice: problems of criminal law, criminal procedure and criminology: Textbook. Moscow: Delo, 2001. 272 p.
Nagaev, V.V. Juvenile justice. Moscow: Unity-Dana: Zakon I pravo, 2009. 252 p.
Prozumentov, L.M. Criminal policy in relation to minors / Gaps in legislation and ways to overcome them: Collection of scientific articles on the results of the International Scientific and Practical Conference September 14 - 15, 2007 / Ed. V.I. Kantina, S.V. Izosimov, A. Yu. Chuprova. N. Novgorod: Nizhny Novgorod Academy of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia, 2008. P.p. 528 - 530.
Predeina, I.V. Legal and theoretical bases of development of juvenile justice in Russia: Author's abstract of dissertation ... Cand. sc. (jurisprudence). Saratov, 2006. 210 p.
Decree of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation of February 1, 2011 No. 1 "On judicial practice of applying legislation regulating the specifics of criminal responsibility and punishment of minors" // Bulletin of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation. №4. 2011.
Decree of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation of 30 June 2015 No. 29 "On the practice of courts applying legislation that provides the right to protection in criminal proceedings // SPS" Consultant Plus ": Version of Prof. [Electronic resource].
Pozdnyakov, V.M. Psychological aspects of the boundaries of the humanization of criminal and penal enforcement legislation in relation to juvenile offenders // Bulletin of the Institute: Crime, Punishment, Correction. 2015. № 4 (32). P.p.64-67.
Sapun, V.A. The theory of legal means and the mechanism of the realization of law. SPb .: SPb GUP, 2002. ("New in the Humanities" series, issue 8). 156 p.
Seroshtan, V.V. Tendencies of improving legislation in the field of ensuring rights in the criminal process of minors // Zakon i pravo. 2009. № 2. P.p.15-16.
Sklizkov, A.N. Interaction of the parties to criminal proceedings at the stage of preliminary investigation // Advocacy practice. 2007. № 3. P.p.21 - 25.
Smirnova, I.G. Social value of the Russian criminal justice: an objectified criterion for evaluation // Social competence. 2017. Vol. 2. № 1 (3). P.52-58.
Snegireva, N.I. Ensuring the rights and legitimate interests of minors in criminal proceedings at the stage of preliminary investigation: Author's abstract of dissertation ... Cand. sc. (jurisprudence). Voronezh, 2001, 25 p.
Spesivov, N.V. International standards for the implementation of criminal justice with the participation of minors and their implementation in the modern Russian criminal process. Author's abstract of dissertation ... Cand. sc. (jurisprudence). Saratov, 2015, 29 p.
Stolbina, L.V., Ozerov, I.N., Severin, N.N., Domracheva, E.Yu. Ensuring the rights of juvenile suspects (accused) in static and dynamic aspects // All-Russian Criminological Journal. 2017. Vol.11. №1. P.p.172-179.
Stetsovsky, Yu. I. Questions of the right of a minor defendant to defense in the stage of preliminary investigation. Training. Volgograd .: Research and editorial and publishing department, 1979. 280 p.
Streltsova, E.V. Tactical and psychological bases of interrogation of underage suspects, accused: Author's abstract of dissertation ... Cand. sc. (jurisprudence). Saratov, 2007. 25p.
Sukhov, A.N. Social psychology of criminality: textbook. Moscow: Moscow Psychological and Social Institute. 2007. 568 p.
Sycheva, N.V. The introduction of the position of an attorney in an educational institution / Problems of protection of the rights of minors and the prevention of violations in the youth environment. In 2 parts. Part 1: Sat. materials of the International Scientific and Practical Conference / Ed. I. Yu. Bliasova. - Shadrinsk: ShKPI, 2010. P.p. 120 - 124.
Solonnikova, N.V. Problems of the procedural capacity of minors in criminal proceedings (pre-trial proceedings). Dissertation ... Cand. sc. (jurisprudence). Krasnodar, 2008. 198p.
Trunov, I.L., Aivar, L.K. Questions of criminal policy in relation to minors // Journal of Russian Law. №10. 2005. P.p.27-38.
Tetyuyev, S.V. Use of pedagogical and psychological knowledge in criminal proceedings involving minors. Ed. A.V. Kudryavtseva. Moscow: Yurlitinform, 2009. 278p.
Trashkova, S.M. The legal status of the personality of juvenile suspects at the stage of initiating a criminal case and guaranteeing its implementation in criminal cases of public accusation: Dissertation ... Cand. sc. (jurisprudence). Barnaul, 2006. 290 p.
Criminal case No. 2-28-09 // Archive of the Supreme Court of the Republic of Sakha (Yakutia).
Criminal case No. 1-1319-06 // Archive of the Yakut City Court of the Republic of Sakha (Yakutia).
Criminal case No. 1-2813-10 // Archive of the Yakutsk City Court of the Republic of Sakha (Yakutia).
Criminal cases No. 1-1231-08 / / Archive of the Yakutsk City Court of the Republic of Sakha (Yakutia).
Criminal case No. 1-2019-08 // Archive of the Yakutsk City Court of the Republic of Sakha (Yakutia).
Criminal case No. 1-322-09 // Archives of the Yakutsk City Court of the Republic of Sakha (Yakutia).
Criminal case No. 1-561-10 // Archive of the Yakutsk City Court of the Republic of Sakha (Yakutia).
Usarov, M. I. The right to a complaint as a principle of criminal procedure and a means of protecting the rights of minors accused and victims in the stage of preliminary investigation: Dissertation ... Cand. sc. (jurisprudence). M., 2004. 178 p.
Khalikov, A.N. Questions of Observance of Human Rights and Freedoms in the Activity of the Investigator / Problems of Legal Protection of Human Values in Modern Russia. Conference materials / ed. Enikeeva Z. D. Ufa: Bashu, 2005. Part 3. P.p. 242-248.
Chashin, A.N. Juvenal justice. Ed. A.N. Chashin. Moscow: Case and Service, 2014. 112 p.
Chebotareva, I. N. Coercion of the suspect, accused of exercising the right to defense // Advocacy practice. 2016. № 5. P.17 - 23.
Chistyakov, A.A., Zinin, G. Yu. Criminological possibilities of legislative consolidation of the recidivism of minors // Man, crime and punishment. 2017. Vol. 25. №3. P.p. 363-371.
Churkin, A. V. Criminal Procedural Questions of Prevention by the Advocate of Offenses // Advocacy. 2001. №4. P.p. 24-25;
Shestakova, L.A. Criminal proceedings in relation to minors: problems of law enforcement // Economics, law, management. 2013. № 4 (4). P.p. 101-107.
Shadrin, V.S. Ensuring the rights of the individual in the investigation of crimes. M., 2000. P.p. 43 - 44.
Proceedings, Vestnik Institute: Crime, Punishment, Correction. 2014. №2. P.p.41-45. Shatalov, A.S. Ensuring the Rights and Legal Interests of Minors in Criminal
Yastrebov, O.A., Morozov, N.I., Morozova, A.N., Kornev, A.V., et al. Juvenile jurisprudence. Textbook in 4 volumes. Edited by N.I. Morozov, A.N. Morozova. Vol.3. M .: Prometey Publishing House, LLC. 356 p.
Agaltsova, M.V. The development of juvenile justice in the countries of the Council of Europe / Improving the mechanisms of working with juvenile offenders in the Russian Federation. Collection of analytical materials. M .: Informpoligraf, LLC. 2010. P.p.52-59.
Arutunyan, A.A. Mediation in criminal proceedings. Moscow: Infotropic Media, 2013. 200 p.
Balakina, V.S. Features of the lawyer's work with under-aged clients // Prospects for the development of juvenile law and juvenile justice in the Russian Federation: materials of the All-Russian Scientific and Practical Conference / Comp. L.A. Chikin, A.V. Yakovlev. Pomor State University named after M.V. Lomonosov. Arkhangelsk: Pomor University, 2008. P.p.11-17.
Bydantsev, N.A. Termination of criminal prosecution (case) against a minor with the use of compulsory measures of educational influence in the aspect of juvenile justice: monograph. M .: Shumilova I.M. Publishing house, 2008. 159 p.
Borisevich, G.Ya. On the implementation of the ideas of juvenile justice in the criminal justice of Russia // Bulletin of Perm University. Juridical sciences. 2015. № 1 (27). P.p.93-104.
Borovik, O.V. Peculiarities of pre-trial proceedings in criminal cases in relation to minors: diss ... cand. sc. (jurisprudence). M, 2006. 176p.
Vasilenko, A.S. Use of elements of restorative justice in criminal proceedings against minors in Russia and the USA / A.S. Vasilenko, L.T.Chikhladze, S.M. Naurzalieva // Man: crime and punishment. 2017. Vol. 25 (1-4). № 3. P.p. 394-398.
Vaske, E.V. Evolution of juvenile delinquency in Russia: a psychological and legal analysis. Moscow: Genesis, 2010. 428 p.
Volodina, L.M. Problems in the theory of the criminal process / Collection of articles on the materials of the International Scientific and Practical Conference "Scientific School of Criminal Process and Criminalistics of St. Petersburg State University and Modern Legal Science". Krasnoyarsk: Center for Social and Legal Technologies, 2016. P.p.59-68.
Volynskaya, O.V. Termination of the criminal case and criminal prosecution: theoretical and organizational and legal problems: monograph. Moscow: Unity-Dana: Zakon I pravo, 2007. 256 p.
The Universal Declaration of Human Rights (adopted at the third session of the UN General Assembly by resolution 217 a (III) of December 10, 1948) // The Garant system. [Electronic resource].
Gukovskaya, N.I., Dolgova, A.I., Minkovsky, G.M. Investigation and trial of cases of crimes of minors. M., 1974. 290 p.
Dudina, A.N. The concept and signs of peremptory norms of law (theoretical and legal analysis). // Izvestiya of the Irkutsk State Economic Academy (Baikal State University of Economics and Law). 2015. Vol.6, №2. P.p.22-31.
Dikarev, I.S. The principle of increased protection of the rights and legitimate interests of minors // Russian Justice. 2007. № 5. P.p. 24-26.
Zabuga, E.E. Mediation as an alternative form of criminal prosecution of minors. Diss. ... cand. jurid. sciences. Omsk, 2014. 261 p.
Kalugina, N.G. Ethical bases of separate investigative actions in cases of crimes of minors. Abstract of diss. .... Cand. sc. (jurisprudence). Izhevsk, 1996, 24p.
Koludarova, O.P. Production in criminal cases against neglected minors of suspects, accused. Abstract of diss. .... Cand. sc. (jurisprudence). Izhevsk, 2011. 29 p.
Kiryanina, N.A. Ensuring the rights of minors in criminal proceedings in the stage of the criminal case: Author's abstract of dissertation ... Cand. sc. (jurisprudence). Nizhny Novgorod, 2010. 28 p.
Kirsanov, V.N. Psychopathology of adolescence / Support for juvenile justice: a methodical manual for judges. Saratov: Publishing house "Saratov State Academy of Law", 2003. P.p.42 - 48.
Konin, V. V, Mukhina, G.A. Protection of minors: establishment of psychological contact / Actual problems of criminal proceedings in relation to minors: materials of the All-Russian Scientific and Practical Conference (November 23, 2007). Kaliningrad .: Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia, 2008. P.p. 58 - 62.
Kolokolov, N.A., Revina, I.V., Ryabinina, T.K., Chebotareva, I.N., Eriashvili, N.D. Lawyer in criminal proceedings. M .: Unity - Dana: Zakon I pravo, 2012. 375 p.
Kostina, L.N. Features of interaction of the investigator with the officers of the inquiry and the psychologist in enhancing the effectiveness of the investigation and prevention of juvenile crimes. Human and civil rights and freedoms: Actual problems of science and practice: Proceedings of the II International Scientific and Practical Conference. Orel: ORAGS Publishing House, 2011. P.p.299 - 307;
Kolpakova, L.A., Rudakov, A.M. The system of juvenile justice in Russia and abroad: monograph. Vologda: Vologda Institute of Economics and Law of the Federal Penitentiary Service of Russia, 2016. 109 p.
Levchenko, O. V., Mishchenko, E. V. Legal basis for criminal proceedings in relation to minors: Monograph. Moscow: INFRA-M, 2012. 125 p.
Lunichev, E.M. The status of a minor in criminal law: monograph / otv. Ed. AI Chuchaev. Moscow: Prospekt, 2012. 144 p.
Makhov, V.N., Vasilenko, A.S., Chebukhanova, L.V. Elements of Restorative Justice in Criminal Proceedings // Bulletin of Perm University. Juridical sciences. 2017. № 35. P.p.107 - 121;
Markovicheva, E.V. Juvenualnoe criminal justice proceedings. Models, functions, principles: monograph. M .: UNITY-DANA: Zakon I pravo, 2010. 271 p.
The UN Standard Minimum Rules for the Administration of Juvenile Justice ("The Beijing Rules") (adopted by UN General Assembly Resolution 40/33 of December 10, 1985) // The Garant System. [Electronic resource].
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights of December 16, 1966 // SPS "Consultant Plus". [Electronic resource].
Convention on the Rights of the Child (New York, November 20, 1989) // The Garant System. [Electronic resource].
Melnikova, E.B. Juvenile justice: problems of criminal law, criminal procedure and criminology: Textbook. Moscow: Delo, 2001. 272 p.
Nagaev, V.V. Juvenile justice. Moscow: Unity-Dana: Zakon I pravo, 2009. 252 p.
Prozumentov, L.M. Criminal policy in relation to minors / Gaps in legislation and ways to overcome them: Collection of scientific articles on the results of the International Scientific and Practical Conference September 14 - 15, 2007 / Ed. V.I. Kantina, S.V. Izosimov, A. Yu. Chuprova. N. Novgorod: Nizhny Novgorod Academy of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia, 2008. P.p. 528 - 530.
Predeina, I.V. Legal and theoretical bases of development of juvenile justice in Russia: Author's abstract of dissertation ... Cand. sc. (jurisprudence). Saratov, 2006. 210 p.
Decree of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation of February 1, 2011 No. 1 "On judicial practice of applying legislation regulating the specifics of criminal responsibility and punishment of minors" // Bulletin of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation. №4. 2011.
Decree of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation of 30 June 2015 No. 29 "On the practice of courts applying legislation that provides the right to protection in criminal proceedings // SPS" Consultant Plus ": Version of Prof. [Electronic resource].
Pozdnyakov, V.M. Psychological aspects of the boundaries of the humanization of criminal and penal enforcement legislation in relation to juvenile offenders // Bulletin of the Institute: Crime, Punishment, Correction. 2015. № 4 (32). P.p.64-67.
Sapun, V.A. The theory of legal means and the mechanism of the realization of law. SPb .: SPb GUP, 2002. ("New in the Humanities" series, issue 8). 156 p.
Seroshtan, V.V. Tendencies of improving legislation in the field of ensuring rights in the criminal process of minors // Zakon i pravo. 2009. № 2. P.p.15-16.
Sklizkov, A.N. Interaction of the parties to criminal proceedings at the stage of preliminary investigation // Advocacy practice. 2007. № 3. P.p.21 - 25.
Smirnova, I.G. Social value of the Russian criminal justice: an objectified criterion for evaluation // Social competence. 2017. Vol. 2. № 1 (3). P.52-58.
Snegireva, N.I. Ensuring the rights and legitimate interests of minors in criminal proceedings at the stage of preliminary investigation: Author's abstract of dissertation ... Cand. sc. (jurisprudence). Voronezh, 2001, 25 p.
Spesivov, N.V. International standards for the implementation of criminal justice with the participation of minors and their implementation in the modern Russian criminal process. Author's abstract of dissertation ... Cand. sc. (jurisprudence). Saratov, 2015, 29 p.
Stolbina, L.V., Ozerov, I.N., Severin, N.N., Domracheva, E.Yu. Ensuring the rights of juvenile suspects (accused) in static and dynamic aspects // All-Russian Criminological Journal. 2017. Vol.11. №1. P.p.172-179.
Stetsovsky, Yu. I. Questions of the right of a minor defendant to defense in the stage of preliminary investigation. Training. Volgograd .: Research and editorial and publishing department, 1979. 280 p.
Streltsova, E.V. Tactical and psychological bases of interrogation of underage suspects, accused: Author's abstract of dissertation ... Cand. sc. (jurisprudence). Saratov, 2007. 25p.
Sukhov, A.N. Social psychology of criminality: textbook. Moscow: Moscow Psychological and Social Institute. 2007. 568 p.
Sycheva, N.V. The introduction of the position of an attorney in an educational institution / Problems of protection of the rights of minors and the prevention of violations in the youth environment. In 2 parts. Part 1: Sat. materials of the International Scientific and Practical Conference / Ed. I. Yu. Bliasova. - Shadrinsk: ShKPI, 2010. P.p. 120 - 124.
Solonnikova, N.V. Problems of the procedural capacity of minors in criminal proceedings (pre-trial proceedings). Dissertation ... Cand. sc. (jurisprudence). Krasnodar, 2008. 198p.
Trunov, I.L., Aivar, L.K. Questions of criminal policy in relation to minors // Journal of Russian Law. №10. 2005. P.p.27-38.
Tetyuyev, S.V. Use of pedagogical and psychological knowledge in criminal proceedings involving minors. Ed. A.V. Kudryavtseva. Moscow: Yurlitinform, 2009. 278p.
Trashkova, S.M. The legal status of the personality of juvenile suspects at the stage of initiating a criminal case and guaranteeing its implementation in criminal cases of public accusation: Dissertation ... Cand. sc. (jurisprudence). Barnaul, 2006. 290 p.
Criminal case No. 2-28-09 // Archive of the Supreme Court of the Republic of Sakha (Yakutia).
Criminal case No. 1-1319-06 // Archive of the Yakut City Court of the Republic of Sakha (Yakutia).
Criminal case No. 1-2813-10 // Archive of the Yakutsk City Court of the Republic of Sakha (Yakutia).
Criminal cases No. 1-1231-08 / / Archive of the Yakutsk City Court of the Republic of Sakha (Yakutia).
Criminal case No. 1-2019-08 // Archive of the Yakutsk City Court of the Republic of Sakha (Yakutia).
Criminal case No. 1-322-09 // Archives of the Yakutsk City Court of the Republic of Sakha (Yakutia).
Criminal case No. 1-561-10 // Archive of the Yakutsk City Court of the Republic of Sakha (Yakutia).
Usarov, M. I. The right to a complaint as a principle of criminal procedure and a means of protecting the rights of minors accused and victims in the stage of preliminary investigation: Dissertation ... Cand. sc. (jurisprudence). M., 2004. 178 p.
Khalikov, A.N. Questions of Observance of Human Rights and Freedoms in the Activity of the Investigator / Problems of Legal Protection of Human Values in Modern Russia. Conference materials / ed. Enikeeva Z. D. Ufa: Bashu, 2005. Part 3. P.p. 242-248.
Chashin, A.N. Juvenal justice. Ed. A.N. Chashin. Moscow: Case and Service, 2014. 112 p.
Chebotareva, I. N. Coercion of the suspect, accused of exercising the right to defense // Advocacy practice. 2016. № 5. P.17 - 23.
Chistyakov, A.A., Zinin, G. Yu. Criminological possibilities of legislative consolidation of the recidivism of minors // Man, crime and punishment. 2017. Vol. 25. №3. P.p. 363-371.
Churkin, A. V. Criminal Procedural Questions of Prevention by the Advocate of Offenses // Advocacy. 2001. №4. P.p. 24-25;
Shestakova, L.A. Criminal proceedings in relation to minors: problems of law enforcement // Economics, law, management. 2013. № 4 (4). P.p. 101-107.
Shadrin, V.S. Ensuring the rights of the individual in the investigation of crimes. M., 2000. P.p. 43 - 44.
Proceedings, Vestnik Institute: Crime, Punishment, Correction. 2014. №2. P.p.41-45. Shatalov, A.S. Ensuring the Rights and Legal Interests of Minors in Criminal
Yastrebov, O.A., Morozov, N.I., Morozova, A.N., Kornev, A.V., et al. Juvenile jurisprudence. Textbook in 4 volumes. Edited by N.I. Morozov, A.N. Morozova. Vol.3. M .: Prometey Publishing House, LLC. 356 p.
Downloads
Publicado
2020-04-23
Como Citar
I. KORYAKINA, Z. .; S. SHATALOV, A. . THE RIGHT TO DEFENSE OF THE MINOR SUSPECTS AND ACCUSED IN THE CRIMINAL PROCEDURAL LEGISLATION OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION. Gênero & Direito, [S. l.], v. 9, n. 03, 2020. Disponível em: https://periodicos.ufpb.br/index.php/ged/article/view/51728. Acesso em: 22 nov. 2024.
Edição
Seção
Seção Livre
