CRIMINAL PRIVILEGE OF AN ATTORNEY AND DEFENCE LAWYER

  • Yulia V. Gracheva Kutafin Moscow State Law University
  • Sergey V. Malikov Kutafin Moscow State Law University
  • Alexandr I. Chuchaev Kutafin Moscow State Law University
Palavras-chave: attorney-client privilege; privilege re-striction; immunity; attorney responsibil-ity; refusal to testify

Resumo

The boundaries of the attorney-client privilege are the main issue of theory and practice that directly touches upon the content of the criminal privilege of an attorney and defense lawyer. In procedural law branches the prohibition of their examination is acknowledged axiomatic. The paper calls attention to the existing moral and legal problem associated with preserving the attorney-client privilege in all the circumstances without exception, including the cases when the disclosure thereof can be justified from the point of view of protecting the interests of a person, society and state. The authors admit the possibility of restriction thereof provided that the law reflects an exhaustive list of crimes, the information on preparation or commission of which will not fall under the content of the attorney-client privilege. As a result it is proposed to eliminate the existing gap in the criminal legislation of RF that can be used in the foreign law. The conclusions made by the authors are based on analyzing the judicial practice of the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) for a period of 1980-2017; decisions and ruling of the Constitutional Court of RF made in 2001-2017; published judicial practice of the RF Supreme Court for 2003-2017; and results of the survey of 78 respondents (judges, prosecution office staff, attorneys and teachers of criminal law and proceedings).

Referências

Collected Legislation of RF. 2002, No. 23, Art. 2102.

Vatman D.P. Advokatskaya etika [Le-gal ethics]. Moscow, 1977. p. 40.

Benedict E. Defense Attorney of Mod-ern Times. Translated from German by Zeiliger T.O. St. Petersburg, 1910. pp. 74. Mittermaier C.J. Rukovodstvo k sudebnoy zashchite [A guide to judicial protection]. Moscow, 1863. pp. 48-49.

Bentam I. About judicial evidence. Translated from French by Goronovich I. Kiev, 1876. pp. 272-273.

Constitution of the Russian Federation. List of acts of constitutional value 1600-1918.

Rabochiy sud. 1923. No. 10, pp. 44-45

Statutory acts of USSR. Available at: www.libussr.ru/.

SPS “KonsultantPlyus.”

Ibidem.

“Vestnik sovetskoy yustitsii” (1924. No. 11, pp. 308-313).

Skerst Vlad “Boundaries of Professional Privilege of Defense Lawyer in the Spir-it of the Soviet Legislation.” p. 311.

Ibidem.

Tsypkin A.L. Advo-katskaya taina [At-torney-client privilege]. Saratov, 1947, p. 6.

Fishman L. On legal ethics. Rabochiy sud. 1924. No. 8-10.

Senchov V. Defense law-yer in criminal proceedings. Rabochiy sud. 1924. No. 8-10.

Rubinshtein L. Ugolovnyi sud RSFSR [Criminal court of RSFSR]. Moscow, 1926.

Obukhovskiy V. Ugolov-nye doka-zatelstva v istorii sovetskogo prava [Criminal evidence in the history of So-viet law]. Kharkov, 1926.

Elkind P.S. Legal ethics. Sovetskaya yustitsiya [Soviet justice]. 1940. № 4.

Zakon RSFSR ot 25 iyulya 1962 g. «Ob utverzhdenii Polozheniya ob advokature RSFSR» Advokatura: Sbornik doku-mentov. RSFSR Law as of July 25, 1962 “On approval of the Statute on the bar of RSFSR.” The Bar - collected documents. Moscow, 2005. p. 37.

Statutory acts of USSR. Available at: www.libussr.ru/.

Zakon RSFSR ot 20 noyabrya 1980 g. «Ob utverzhdenii Polozheniya ob advo-kature RSFSR» Advokatura: Sbornik dokumentov. RSFSR Law as of No-vember 20, 1980 “On approval of the Statute on the Bar of RSFSR.” The Bar - collected documents. Moscow, 2005. p. 118.

Zalogina O.G. Institute of the attorney-client privilege in the Soviet times: prob-lems of establishment and improvement. Materialy nauchnoi konferentsii, Ufa, 2012 (Materials of Scientific Confer-ence in Ufa, 2012), Ufa, 2012. p. 12.

Tsypkin A.L. Advokatskaya taina [At-torney-client privilege]. p. 18.

Kucherina A.G. Attorney-client privi-lege. Zakonnost (Legitimacy). 2003, No. 2. p. 47

Biznes v zakone [Business in law]. 2008, No. 4. p. 240 ).

Barshchevskiy M.Yu. Advo-katskaya etika [Attorney-client privilege]. Mos-cow, 2000. p. 110.

SPS “KonsultantPlyus.”

Tsypkin A.L. Attorney-client privilege. Voprosy advokatury (Defense attorney issues). 2001, No. 2. p. 62.

Podolnyi N.A. Attorney-client privilege and problems of securing public safety from terrorism and organized crime. Advokatskaya praktika (Legal practice) 2005, No. 1. p. 8.

Boltnev V.K. Attorney-client privilege. Biznes v zakone (Business in Law). 2010, No. 4. p. 145.

Collected Legislation of RF. 2001, No. 33 ( P. 1). Art. 3418,

Advokatskaya praktika [Legal practice]. 2013, No. 2.

Petrukhin I.L. Lichnye tayny (chelovek i vlast) [Personal secrets (man and pow-er)]. Moscow, 1998. p. 151.

Comment to the Federal Law “On ad-vocacy activity and the bar in the Rus-sian Federation.” Moscow, 2004. p. 85

Aria S.L. On Attorney-client privilege. Life of Attorney. Moscow, 2010. p. 45.
Ref. about it in detail: Bu-robin V.N., PletnevV.Yu., Shubin D.A. Advo-katskaya taina. [Attorney-client privi-lege] Moscow, 2006.

Zakomoldin A.V. Attorney-client privi-lege and enforcement of the right for qualified legal assistance in criminal procedure in Russia/ Evraziiskaya advo-katura [Eurasian defense attorneys]. 2013, No. 6 (7), pp. 48-50.

Pilipenko S.Yu. National doctrine on the absoluteness or relativity of the at-torney-client privilege. Advokatskaya praktika [Legal practice]. 2009, No. 6. p. 17.

ibidem p. 21.

Stetsov-skiy Yu.I. Principle of the at-torney-client confidentiality. Advokat [Lawyer]. 2008, No. 3.

Makarova Z.V. Professionalnaya zash-chita podozrevaemykh, obvinyaemykh [Professional protection of alleged crim-inals and defendants]. St. Petersburg, 2008. pp. 139-140.
Publicado
2020-04-23
Como Citar
V. GRACHEVA, Y.; V. MALIKOV, S.; I. CHUCHAEV, A. CRIMINAL PRIVILEGE OF AN ATTORNEY AND DEFENCE LAWYER. Gênero & Direito, v. 9, n. 03, 23 abr. 2020.
Seção
Seção Livre