THEORETICAL APPROACHES TO THE DEFINITION OF “LAND TRANSFER” AND “LAND PLOT TRANSFERABILITY” IN THE RUSSIAN LAND AND CIVIL LAW
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.22478/ufpb.2179-7137.2020v9n03.51681Palavras-chave:
land transfer, agricultural land plot transferability, grounds for the creation of land plot titles, acts of public authorities and local government bodies, consummation of civil transactions, civil and public turnover.Resumo
the relevance of the problem under study is due to the fact that scientific concepts do not offer a shared vision of the essence of transferability and types of agricultural land plot transfer. Analysis of the problems arising in this sphere provided herein is of major importance to land and civil law. The article is aimed at formulating a theoretical definition of land transfer, which may apply to land plots of any categories not withdrawn from transfer, including transfer of agricultural land plots. The leading approach to the study of the problem at hand is the logical method of system analysis, which allows to educe peculiarities of agricultural land transfer conditioned by specific features of a transferable item. The research article yields the following main results: it uses the data of comprehensive study of the law and specialist scholarly literature to identify the peculiarities of both public and private agricultural land plot transfer and offers the author’s definition of transfer. The article provides arguments for the recognition of public (administrative) transfer as a variety of land transfer. The article justifies the need to specify general principles of determining transferability of land plots of any category, including land plots from agricultural land, in the Russian Land Code. Article materials may be of use when developing the land law theory, expanding the theory of agricultural land transfer regulation, in the elaboration of some fundamental definitions and scientific classifications and in the theoretical justification of lines of improvement of the land transfer law. The theoretical suggestions provided may be used when teaching land law, individual sections in the civil law course and when preparing textbooks, teaching aids and study guides.
Downloads
Referências
Anisimov A.P., Dzagoev S.V., Kokoeva L.T. Acquisition of Titles to Land in Public Ownership: Theory and Practice [Priobreteniye prav na zemelnyye uchastki, nakhodyashchiyesya v publichnoy sobstvennosti: voprosy teorii i praktiki] / edited by A.Ya. Ryzhenkov. Moscow, New Index. 2009. P. 80.
Andreev Yu.N. Rights of Participants of Agricultural Commercial Organizations and Their Legal Protection [Prava uchastnikov selskokhozyaystvennykh kommercheskikh organizatsiy i ikh sudebnaya zashchita]. Extended abstract of the Dr. habil. thesis in Law. Moscow, 2000. P. 9.
Bratyus S.N. Subject and System of Soviet Civil Law [Predmet i sistema sovetskogo grazhdanskogo prava]. Moscow, 1963. P. 118.
Vedenin N.N. Legal Status of State Farms in the Context of the Economic Reform [Pravovoye polozheniye sovkhozov v usloviyakh ekonomicheskoy reformy]. Moscow, 1973. P. 157.
Grigoriev V.K. Soviet Land Law [Sovetskoye zemelnoye pravo]. Moscow, 1957. P. 9.
Volkov G.A., Golichenkov A.K., Kozyr O.M.. Land Market Development: Legal Aspect [Razvitiye rynka zemli: pravovoy aspekt] // State and Law. 1998. No. 2. P. 50.
Gerasin S.I. Legal Framework of Agricultural Production Land Transfer [Pravovyye osnovy oborota zemel, ispolzuyemykh v selskokhozyaystvennom proizvodstve]. Extended abstract of the Ph.D. thesis in Law. Moscow, 2000. P. 8.
Zharikov Yu.G. Theoretical Problems of Agricultural Land Use in the USSR [Teoreticheskiye problemy selskokhozyaystvennogo zemlepolzovaniya v SSSR]. Extended abstract of the Dr. habil. thesis in Law. Moscow, 1974. P. 7.
Zhernakov D.V. Legal Status of Land as Civil Turnover Objects [Pravovoy rezhim zemelnykh uchastkov kak obyektov grazhdanskogo oborota]. Extended abstract of the Ph.D. thesis in Law. Yekaterinburg, 2005. P. 20.
Ikonitskaya I.A., Krasnov N.I. Regulatory Management of Market Transfer of Agricultural Land [Pravovoye regulirovaniye rynochnogo oborota selskokhozyaystvennykh zemel] // Title to Land in Russian Agriculture. Moscow, 1996. P. 79-102.
Ikonitskaya I.A. Certain Theoretical Matters of State Land Ownership [Nekotoryye teoreticheskiye voprosy prava gosudarstvennoy sobstvennosti na zemlyu] // Russian Law Journal. 2006. No. 12.
Krasnov N.I. Legal Groundwork of Efficient Land Use in the USSR [Pravovoye obespecheniye ratsionalnogo ispolzovaniya zemli v SSSR]. Moscow, 1969. P. 12.
Krylatykh E.N. Origin and Development of the Land Relations Regulation System [Stanovleniye i razvitiye sistemy regulirovaniya zemelnykh otnosheniy] // Problems of Forecasting. 1997. No. 1. P. 35.
Kostina O.V. Civil Regulation of Transactions with Agricultural Land and Land Allotments [Grazhdansko-pravovoye regulirovaniye sdelok s zemelnymi uchastkami selskokhozyaystvennoye naznacheniya i zemelnymi dolyami]. Extended abstract of the Ph.D. thesis in Law. Moscow, 2006. P. 16.
Matveev D.V. Land Purchase and Sale Agreement [Dogovor kupli-prodazhi zemelnykh uchastkov]: Extended abstract of the Ph.D. thesis in Law. Kazan, 2005. P. 12
Pasikova T.A. Peculiarities of Civil Turnover of Agricultural Land [Osobennosti grazhdanskogo oborota zemelnykh uchastkov selskokhozyaystvennogo naznacheniya]. Extended abstract of the Ph.D. thesis in Law. Krasnodar 2008. P. 6, 9-10.
Pavlova E.I. Foreign Experience of Legal Regulation of Agricultural Land Lease [Zarubezhnyy opyt pravovogo regulirovaniya arendy selskokhozyaystvennykh zemel] // State and Law. 2002. No. 12. P. 67.
Strautmanis Ya.Ya. Property Features of Land Relations and Imposition of Property Sanctions [Imushchestvennyye cherty zemelnykh otnosheniy i primeneniye imushchestvennykh sanktsiy] // Soviet State and Law. 1981 No. 8. P. 39.
Syrodoev N.A. Legal Regulation of Land Transfer [Pravovoye regulirovaniye oborota zemelnykh uchastkov] // State and Law. 1999. No. 9. P. 41.
Skvortsova Yu.V. Civil Law Relations in Land Transfer in Russia [Grazhdansko-pravovyye otnosheniya v sfere oborota zemelnykh uchastkov v Rossii]. Extended abstract of the Ph.D. thesis in Law. Spb 2004. P. 7, 16.
