The blind leading the blind:

critical analysis of the appropriation on Psychology by BNCC and BNC-Formação

Authors

  • Fernando Cézar Bezerra de Andrade UFPB
  • Catarina Carneiro Gonçalves Departamento de Métodos e Técnicas de Ensino da Universidade Federal de Pernambuco

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.22478/ufpb.2527-1083.2022v7.63676

Abstract

Starting from a reflection on current Brazilian educational public policies for teacher training; and on violence at school (such as bullying and massacres), we aim to demonstrate the fundamental role of Educational Psychology in initial and continuous professional preparation to work at schools. In this scenario, we exam the necessary moral training of those professionals in order to face conflicts in the institutional routine. As in the analogy of the blind leading another one, we discuss a double level of blindness associated with teaching in Brazil: that of the current public educational policies, which submit psychological knowledge to the individualist logic typical of ultra-liberal market, thus accentuating the separation between schooling and life, and preventing a critical-transforming analysis of reality through pedagogical practices; and another, which highlights this blindness in terms of teacher training, both initial and continuing, implicit in this paradox: the need for educators to be morally more evolved, towards moral autonomy, so that they can promote the moral formation of new generations in the same sense, nevertheless is contradicted, since it is more common to find heteronomous educators. And how can morally heteronomous educators collaborate to the moral autonomy of their students? In face of this aporia, we argue, based on Piaget's theory: to neglect the promotion of educators’ moral development strongly helps to reproduce blind conservative practices that are morally less evolved, incapable of producing a cooperative relational environment, required to arouse critical consciences in order to overcome or avoid violence. Our axiom assumes that morally autonomous educators will be more committed to the moral evolution of colleagues and students. The opposite is also true. In sociocultural level, Alfred Bandura’s moral disengagement concepts allow to analyse cognitive processes that support a heteronomous professional culture, resistant to changes and (self)criticism, inclined to repeat inequal power relations in school. If moral development usually does not derive from heteronomous individual value systems, however, pressures to change (progressive or even regressive) come from the school institutional and collective level, in which there are various values and ways of thinking. Hence, social phenomena supplement, at school, individual cognitive limits, prefigured in the analogy with blindness. Educational Psychology makes viable this analysis, producing theoretical and experiential knowledge that illuminates initial and continuing reflective teacher training.

Author Biography

  • Fernando Cézar Bezerra de Andrade, UFPB

    Departamento de Fundamentação da Educação-Área de Psicologia da Educação

Published

01/09/2022

Issue

Section

DIÁLOGOS FUNDAMENTAIS PARA FORMAÇÃO DOCENTE: TEMAS E DESAFIOS DOS FUNDAMENTOS DA

How to Cite

ANDRADE, F. C. B. DE; CARNEIRO GONÇALVES, C. The blind leading the blind: : critical analysis of the appropriation on Psychology by BNCC and BNC-Formação. Revista Educare (Online), v. 7, 1 Sept.2022.

Most read articles by the same author(s)