(EN) On Justification, Justice, and Legitimacy
Keywords:
Politics, Rawls, Habermas, LegitimacyAbstract
I consider three main questions. First, what is the relationship between the concepts of Justification, Justice, and Legitimacy? I approach these concepts from the similar, though divergent, theories as found first in John Rawls, and his theory of Political Liberalism, namely his Justice as Fairness and second in Jürgen Habermas, in his Between Facts and Norms, namely his theories of Communicative Action and Discourse Ethics. Second, what is the proper level of legitimation and justice? Which social institutions are best described as doing the legitimation, and to which does it apply? Third, I offer an argument explaining that legitimacy is not sufficient for a full theory of justice. If justice and legitimacy are divergent concepts, then the latter, as the weaker, singularly fails to deliver a stable social structure. To make this argument, I look at the space between Habermas and Rawls on the subject of Political Liberalism.Downloads
Published
15/09/2012
Issue
Section
Articles
License
Os autores estão cientes de que transferem seus direitos de publicação e distribuição à revista Prima Facie. Os autores autorizam o uso do trabalho para fins não-comerciais, incluindo direito de enviar o trabalho em bases de dados de Acesso Livre. As provas finais poderão não ser enviadas aos autores antes da publicação, seguindo a revista seu padrão técnico explicitado nas suas normas e nos formatos praticados em acordo com a CAPES e com padrões de excelência adotados. As opiniões emitidas pelos autores são de sua exclusiva responsabilidade não sendo a revista solidária da livre opinião exposta por eles.How to Cite
ROBINSON, R. C. (EN) On Justification, Justice, and Legitimacy. Prim@ Facie - Law, History and Politics, v. 10, n. 19, p. 124–144, 15 Sept.2012.